Androvett Legal Media and Marketing
2501 Oak Lawn Avenue  |  Suite 650  |  Dallas, Texas 75219
Tel: 214.559.4630  |  Fax: 214.559.0852


Clients in the News

Client_News

Thompson & Knight Attorney David Furlow quoted in The Gazette
A plea for caution on panhandling ban
 
July 17, 2012 11:59 pm

The Gazette:

Last week, when I wrote about Cedar Rapids' proposed panhandling ordinance, I tossed in some stuff near the end about begging being free speech. I was sort of flip about it.

But for David Furlow, a Houston attorney and historian who has litigated a variety of First Amendment issues as high as the U.S. Supreme Court, it's a serious argument.

"It's a form of speech," Furlow said. "When I put out my hand when you pass by, you're not just seeing an outthrust hand. You're understanding the message conveyed, which is, 'brother can you spare a dime?' That's a form of expressive speech."

Furlow knows most folks don't see it that way. He suggests switching out the panhandler for a pastor seeking donations from the pulpit. "Would anybody doubt that's protected speech? It's all in context," he said.

....

I sent Furlow a copy of Cedar Rapids' draft panhandling ordinance provided by the police department. I know it's being revised, but I wanted to see what he thought about its basic provisions.

A main focus of the ordinance is banning "aggressive panhandling." And Furlow contends that if the City Council sticks strictly to specific, aggressive behavior, it can create an ordinance that restricts conduct but not speech or expression. That way, if it was challenged in court, the city would have a lower legal threshold to clear in proving the ordinance’s necessity.

Thompson & Knight Attorney David Furlow in Gazette article

....

Basically, the council needs to be very careful. Don't overshoot aggressive beggars and hit the Constitution.

http://thegazette.com/2012/07/17/a-plea-for-caution-on-panhandling-ban/

Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group


Send this page to a friend